Mergers and acquisitions are among the boldest—and most uncertain—moves a leader can make. One 2011 study in the Harvard Business Review confirmed the conventional wisdom, putting the M&A failure rate at a staggering 70% to 90%. While more recent analysis from Bain & Company suggests the odds have improved, the bottom line remains: M&A deals are massive, complex undertakings, rife with uncertainty that requires immense courage. A core belief of my book, How to Be Bold, is that courage is not an innate trait, but a muscle that can be built and strengthened. The story of Alaska Airlines’ two most significant acquisitions serves as a masterclass in this very idea—a story of an organization honing and building its courage muscles in real-time.
The 2016 acquisition of Virgin America was, on paper, a strategic home run, giving Alaska crucial routes. The execution, however, revealed the classic tensions that arise when integrating a distinct company with its very own brand, culture, and processes. At the time of the acquisition, Alaska was an 85-year-old carrier built on operational discipline. It absorbed Virgin America—a young brand famous for its freewheeling, personality-driven culture. While both airlines valued employee autonomy, they approached it from opposite ends of the spectrum. Alaska had cultivated what I call “structure that’s not stifling.” Its meticulously constructed “Service Framework” provided a clear structure with four pillars—Safety, Caring, Delivery, and Presentation—but also empowered them to make their own judgment calls to solve customer problems. Virgin’s was more organic, encouraging employees to “bring their whole selves to work.” Theirs was a culture of freedom guided by principles like “Create wow” and “Elevate people,” which empowered employees to solve problems with flair and empathy, leading to service moments but also meant operational challenges and an economic model that wasn’t quite working. In the drive for a single, unified and profitable brand, the structured approach won out, and aspects of the unique “zest” that defined the Virgin experience seemed to have vanished.
The challenges of that experience became the catalyst for a much deeper organizational Comprehension, one of the ‘9 C’s of Courage,’ as Alaska’s leadership, now under CEO Ben Minicucci, approached the 2023 acquisition of Hawaiian Airlines. Instead of a complete absorption of Hawaiian into their fold, the Alaska team sought to take it one step at a time. In so doing, it seems that they realized that this wasn’t just about buying routes; it was an exercise in corporate sensemaking. Sensemaking here refers to the seminal idea developed by Karl Weick that suggests that facing uncertainty, you sometimes take small steps into the unknown and revise and update your thinking as you dive into the unknown. The same seems to be true here. The leadership team had a clear-eyed view of Alaska’s strengths: a vast mainland network, a fiercely loyal customer base powered by its Mileage Plan, and a well-earned reputation for operational excellence, having earned J.D. Power’s highest customer-satisfaction rating for 10 years in a row prior to the Virgin merger. But this time as they ventured into this acquisition, they looked beyond their own strengths to comprehend the true essence of Hawaiian Airlines. They saw that its true value was much more than its fleet; it also was its almost sacred connection to the culture and people of Hawai’i, cultivated over 94 years. The crucial insight was that to weaken that brand would be to negatively impact the very soul of the asset they were acquiring.
This Comprehension through sensemaking led to a courageous Commitment to a radically different and more complex integration strategy—one that preserved the authenticity of the Hawaiian brand while still capturing the powerful synergies of the merger. This nuanced Commitment required a more patient, surgical approach, with concrete proof points already emerging. On the customer-facing side, the Hawaiian Airlines brand, its iconic Pualani aircraft livery, and its unique in-flight service celebrating the Spirit of Aloha are all being retained. This preserves the brand identity that customers know and love, an apparent contrast to the Virgin America integration. Operationally, the loyalty programs have been combined, with HawaiianMiles members transitioned to Alaska’s Mileage Plan at a 1:1 ratio, preserving their status and miles—an immediate, tangible benefit. This back-end alignment also allows for the introduction of Alaska’s flexible “Saver Fare” for Hawaiian flights, combining the strengths of both systems. Furthermore, this merger has unlocked new strategic capabilities. For the first time, Alaska is leveraging Hawaiian’s widebody fleet to launch long-haul international routes, such as Seattle to Tokyo and Seoul. This demonstrates a thoughtful network alignment that supports Alaska’s internationalization efforts without erasing Hawaiian’s unique offerings.
To honor and double down on Hawaiian’s commitment in the local community, Alaska and Hawaiian have jointly created a foundation to support cultural and language programs in both Alaska and Hawai‘i, guided by a dedicated Hawai‘i Community Advisory Board. They have also protected all union jobs at Hawaiian and committed to retaining Honolulu as a major operational base while expanding workforce development programs to cultivate local talent. These proof points illustrate a patient, detailed approach focused on sustaining local jobs, protecting cultural identity, listening to stakeholders, and adding flexible operational value.
The jury is still out on how the integration of Alaska and Hawaiian Airlines will ultimately unfold. However, it is already clear that this is not a faceless corporate merger, nor is it an arm’s length acquisition that fails to capture real synergies. Alaska’s leadership has chosen a difficult, nuanced path guided by the wisdom of experience. Their journey is a powerful illustration of organizational learning in action and a testament to the idea that the greatest courage often lies not in the initial bold move, but in the thoughtful, humble, and disciplined execution that follows.
