The dot-com bust in 2000. The Great Recession of 2008. The COVID-19 pandemic from 2020 to 2022. Every 7 to 10 years, it seems leaders are confronted with a crisis that plunges their organizations into a fog of deep uncertainty. As I write about in my book How to Be Bold, uncertainty often triggers the fear response, where we often default to freezing. Hence, viewed through the lenses of fear and freezing, I define Courage as “action in the face of fear.” But in a crisis, this begs the most important questions of all: what is the optimal action, and how does a leader find the courage to execute it in reality? In these defining moments, the path forward is rarely clear, yet every leader intuitively knows that their response will determine their company’s fate.
Back in 2009, I, along with my co-authors Nitin Nohria and Franz Wohlgezogen, embarked on a year-long project to understand “what” the optimal action is for a firm navigating a recession. We wanted to move beyond folksy wisdom and anecdotes. We analyzed the strategic choices and corporate performance of 4,700 public companies across three global recessions: the 1980 crisis (which lasted from 1980 to 1982), the 1990 slowdown (1990 to 1991), and the 2000 bust (2000 to 2002). We studied them across three periods—the three years before, the three years after, and the recession years themselves—to understand what separated the winners from the survivors, and from those who disappeared entirely.
Our findings were stark and startling. In our study, 17% of the companies didn’t survive a recession: they went bankrupt, were acquired, or became private. The majority of survivors were painfully slow to recover. Only a small number of companies—approximately 9% of our sample—flourished after a slowdown, doing better on key financial parameters than they had before, and outperforming rivals in their industry by at least 10% in terms of sales and profits growth.
What we found was counterintuitive. These postrecession winners weren’t the usual suspects. Firms that cut costs faster and deeper than rivals didn’t necessarily flourish. In fact, they had the lowest probability–21%–of pulling ahead of the competition when times got better. Businesses that boldly invested more than their rivals during a recession also didn’t always fare well either. They enjoyed only a 26% chance of becoming leaders after a downturn. The companies that emerged the strongest were the ones that demonstrated the most disciplined courage, blending temperance with bold action. This disciplined courage, we found, was a specific combination: they reduced costs selectively by focusing on operational efficiency rather than deep layoffs, even as they invested in the future by spending intentionally on strategic assets, R&D initiatives, and commercialization efforts.
A powerful modern example of this playbook at work is that of Airbnb during the COVID-19 pandemic. It’s a masterclass in striking the balance of operational efficiency and strategic investments. When the pandemic vaporized revenue, what the company did was pare back ambitious legacy projects—slashing marketing spend, shutting down new divisions focused on hotels and flights, closing an in-house content studio, and reducing staff by 25%. Simultaneously, it doubled down on its core by supporting its hosts with a $250 million relief fund, and doubled down on its future by pivoting its core product experience to long-term, local stays. However, what was most striking was how Founder & CEO Brian Chesky navigated the crisis. In effect, it was a true masterclass in ‘Calm,’ ‘Comprehension,’ and ‘Commitment,’ three of the ‘9 C’s of Courage’ outlined in How to Be Bold.
When the COVID-19 pandemic hit, Chesky’s response demonstrated mastery in ‘Calm.’ As panic and fear paralyzed the travel industry, Chesky performed a crucial mental shift reinterpreting the situation in his mind. He reframed the crisis not as an end, but as a “moment of clarity” and an opportunity to re-anchor on Airbnb’s core purpose. He famously said, “This crisis has sharpened our focus to get back to our roots.” This act of reframing the situation from an existential threat to a focusing event was the essential first step that broke the “freeze” response and gave him the mental space to act.
This newfound ‘Calm’ allowed for true ‘Comprehension.’ Instead of just cutting costs, Chesky’s team engaged in sensemaking—the core of comprehension. They noticed the trigger (global travel ended, 2020 revenue was forecasted to be less than half of what they earned in 2019) and interpreted the cues (people still wanted to escape, but safely and locally, and with an undercurrent of human connection). This led to a crucial action: the strategic pivot to long-term and local stays. This wasn’t just a guess; it was an insight born from comprehending the new reality. They then retooled their core product experience to support this pivot, adding new features like “I’m Flexible” search options and date flexibility, perfectly matching the new, uncertain world of travel. More fundamentally, they reoriented and rightsized their teams, resources, and capabilities to map to their future, more focused, business strategy.
Finally, Chesky’s actions were anchored by ‘Commitment.’ He doubled down on his “back to basics” narrative, framing it as a moral quest to serve his host community, and offer customers the meaningful experiences they yearned during a challenging time. The $250 million host relief fund was the proof, as was his evenkeeled and honest narrative of why they were making such a dramatic business pivot, what they were now evolving into, how they approached decisions for reductions and changes, and how they planned to support those impacted. As I recount in How to Be Bold, adopting a quest that is decidedly moral unlocks tremendous emotional power. This act had a powerful narrative form: it showed the world a clear obstacle (hosts’ survival) and a practical and reasonable path forward (the fund, the pivot, and the restructuring), demonstrating his commitment to the idea that “Airbnb is its hosts” and it is here to serve its customers in an enduring manner, irrespective of circumstances. Airbnb and Brian Chesky gained critical acclaim for its approach to navigating such a challenging operating environment, with intentionality, honesty, and humanity.
Former Intel CEO Andy Grove once said, “Bad companies are destroyed by crises; good companies survive them; great companies are improved by them.” My research with Nitin Nohria and Franz Wohlgezogen indicates that the difference between “good” and “great” is the courage to act with temperance—to skillfully play both offense and defense. Airbnb is a true masterclass in how a leader achieves this. Chesky didn’t just act; he acted with purpose. He first reframed the crisis to find ‘Calm,’ which then enabled his ‘Comprehension’ to see the new world clearly. Finally, he anchored his most difficult choices in a ‘Commitment’ to his hosts and customers. This gave him the clarity to make a major strategic pivot, proceed with painful cuts, and drive bold, focused investments simultaneously, proving that a crisis is not just a test of survival, but a rare opportunity to define what your company truly stands for.
